# Third Time's the Charm

4.8

(176) reviews

Pizza

$$

Red Hook

[Best of Brooklyn](/content/cities/new-york-ny/list/the-best-of-brooklyn-gems?date=2026-07-28&seats=2&time=all-day/index.html)

[Top Pizza](/content/cities/new-york-ny/list/new-yorks-best-pizza-spots?date=2026-07-28&seats=2&time=all-day/index.html)

[New on Resy](/content/cities/new-york-ny/list/new-on-resy?date=2026-07-28&seats=2&time=all-day/index.html)

---

### Why We Like It

It’s a neighborhood place with real pizza prowess. Chef Chris Milazzo, a self-taught pizzaiolo, experiments with multiple types of ovens to create his vision of a perfect pie, and we are the lucky recipients of his labor. The result is a pizza workshop that also serves up nostalgic bar bites.

Guests  
2 Guests  
3 Guests  
4 Guests  
5 Guests  
6 Guests  
7 Guests  
8+ Guests

### Date

Today

### Time
All Day  
2:30 AM  
3:00 AM  
3:30 AM  
4:00 AM  
4:30 AM  
5:00 AM  
5:30 AM  
6:00 AM  
6:30 AM  
7:00 AM  
7:30 AM  
8:00 AM  
8:30 AM  
9:00 AM  
9:30 AM  
10:00 AM  
10:30 AM  
11:00 AM  
11:30 AM  
12:00 PM  
12:30 PM  
1:00 PM  
1:30 PM  
2:00 PM  
2:30 PM  
3:00 PM  
3:30 PM  
4:00 PM  
4:30 PM  
5:00 PM  
5:30 PM  
6:00 PM  
6:30 PM  
7:00 PM  
7:30 PM  
8:00 PM  
8:30 PM  
9:00 PM  
9:30 PM  
10:00 PM  
10:30 PM  
11:00 PM  
11:30 PM  
12:00 AM  
12:30 AM  
1:00 AM  
1:30 AM  
2:00 AM

---

At the moment, there's no online availability for Today. The next availability for 2 is [Tomorrow](/#).

---

Qualifies for Resy Credit

This venue currently qualifies for the Resy Credit, a benefit for select American Express® Card Members. [Terms apply.](/content/resycredit/index.html)

## Need to Know

All bar seats are first come, first served. Indoor tables, and tables in our enclosed backyard, may be booked up to 22 days in advance -- but walk-ins are always welcome. Most table reservations are for 1 hour and 30 minutes. If you're running late, tables are held for 15 minutes. Please email us at support@charmbarnyc.com to book tables for 8 or more guests. We cannot combine separate reservations for 8 or more guests.

## About Third Time's the Charm

Sourdough pizza, classic cocktails, crushable beers and wines, in a turn-of-the-twentieth century-styled bar room. Current kitchen hours: Wednesday-Thursday, 4-9 p.m.; Friday & Saturday, 12-10 p.m.; Sunday, 12-9 p.m.

[Maps](https://maps.google.com/maps?ll=40.679175,-74.010514&z=15&t=m&hl=en-US&gl=US&mapclient=embed&cid=10738424309660853716 "Maps (opens in new tab)")

|     |     |
| --- | --- |
| `←` | Move left |
| `→` | Move right |
| `↑` | Move up |
| `↓` | Move down |
| `+` | Zoom in |
| `-` | Zoom out |
| `Home` | Jump left by 75% |
| `End` | Jump right by 75% |
| `Page Up` | Jump up by 75% |
| `Page Down` | Jump down by 75% |

### Third Time's the Charm

275 Van Brunt St

Brooklyn, NY 11231

[Get Directions](https://www.google.com/maps/search/Third%20Time's%20the%20Charm%2C275%20Van%20Brunt%20St%2CBrooklyn%2CNY%2C11231)

---

## Discover Third Time's the Charm & More

[**The Hit List**](https://blog.resy.com/category/the-hit-list/) [**The Resy Hit List: Where In New York You’ll Want to Eat in Jan. 2026**](https://blog.resy.com/the-hit-list/nyc-restaurants-jan-2026/)

[**The Rundown**](https://blog.resy.com/category/rundown/) [**With Third Time's the Charm, an Exciting New Pizzeria Emerges in Red Hook**](https://blog.resy.com/2025/10/third-times-the-charm-nyc/)

---